What is 'Chinese Restaurant Syndrome' and what causes it?
This answer is brought to you by many of the Australian
nutrition professionals who regularly contribute to a nutrition email discussion
group.
Chinese Restaurant Syndrome is a combination of symptoms
that include feelings of burning, flushing, tingling and tightness - symptoms
that some people experience after eating a meal from a Chinese restaurant.
For at least thirty years the claim has commonly been made
that monosodium glutamate (MSG) is the cause of Chinese Restaurant Syndrome.
Although a claim that is commonly made may indicate an association or (possibly)
even cause and effect, such a claim must be supported by appropriate studies
before it can be considered to be scientifically valid. Many studies have been
conducted to test the claim about MSG and Chinese Restaurant Syndrome. Some (but
by no means all) studies have reported finding a relationship between MSG and
the syndrome.
Evidently, in a small group of people, the concentrations
of MSG added to meals served at some Chinese restaurants consistently trigger
the symptoms of Chinese Restaurant Syndrome. Because this association is not
consistently reproducible in all sufferers, it appears that some people who
experience symptoms are responding to something other than MSG.
Another possible cause (among several) is the high salt
level of many Chinese foods - excessive salt was suggested by the doctor who
first described the syndrome (Dr Kwok), as a more likely cause than MSG.
Clearly, the last word on the food components that trigger
the symptoms of Chinese Restaurant Syndrome has not been spoken (or written).
More carefully-designed studies are needed before all of the causes of this
syndrome are identified, but it does appear that MSG is one cause, at least for
some people.
As a cautionary measure, it would be prudent to avoid
choosing the saltiest items on the menu in a Chinese restaurant; the waiter can
tell you (or find out for you) which items are the saltiest. People who know
they are intolerant to MSG can usually handle the natural MSG content of foods
such as tomatoes and mushrooms, and can simply ask for a meal with no added MSG.
Back to Frequently Asked Questions
Index
[Date issued: May 1999]
Disclaimer: This material is provided on the basis that it
constitutes advice of a general nature only. It is not intended to replace the
advice of a physician or a dietitian.
|